Anvil versus Bypass Secateurs
Tony Matson - Monday, November 06, 2017
I often give talks at Garden Clubs and ask the question "What is the most important tool in the Garden Shed?" Invariably the answer is 'secateurs' so I though it would be worth discussing the merits of Anvil vs. Bypass Secateurs. Many people have more than one pair.
Anvil secateurs have an upper
blade that is sharp both sides and cuts down onto a flat lower 'anvil'.
This anvil can be metal or have a hard plastic insert. The action is much
like a guillotine or a knife on a chopping board. With a blade sharp on
both sides, pruning harder stems will be easier.
For tougher or woodier stems,
a pair of anvil secateurs is recommended. The majority of ratchet secateurs are
of the anvil design. Some people suggest that anvil secateurs shouldn't
be used to cut green material because it will be squashed rather than
cut. However, there are a lot of experienced (mature) gardeners that find
the ratchet anvil secateurs very useful.
Anvil secateurs are also good
for both right and left handers. The top handle is flat and the safety
latch is in the central position.
As indicated, ratchet secateurs are
extremely popular with gardeners with tendonitis, arthritis and/or those with
declining strength. Most of these people have lovely gardens and are not causing their plants to die by using anvil secateurs.
Bypass secateurs have a convex shaped blade, sharp only on the outer edge cutting down beside an anvil or non-sharp hook concave in shape. The anvil or hook is typically smaller on bypass secateurs.Bypass secateurs are the most common type, used for pruning live stems and where you need to make sharp, precise cuts. They are more suitable for cutting softer, stringier living stems as the blade cuts all the way through the stem. Bypass secateurs can cut smaller stems right against a larger stem and due to this functionality nursery people will typically use this type of secateur. The majority of bypass secateurs are designed for right handers with a tapered handle, with the outside edge of the blade on the right side and safety latch controlled by the right thumb. Harder or dead stems may cause the stem to bend rather than be cut, and get caught between the blade and the hook. This can cause the two sections to separate resulting in damage to your secateurs.
In summary - for the average gardener who is not grafting or propagating either the anvil or bypass secateurs will be suitable. In an ideal situation where either blade is sharp you will get a nice clean cut on living tissue.The anvil secateurs are more useful for harder wood as both sides of the blade is sharp and since the blade is like a guillotine, is less likely to cause damage (separation of the blade and hook). These are very effective with lots of shrubs to prune, or cutting up to stems for the compost bin. They also are invaluable if you are loosing strength or have arthritis or tendonitis.If you are cutting flowers and herbs/ spices I recommend bypass style secateurs.Whilst there is a lot to be said for using the "right tool for the right job" it is more important to get the right secateurs for you. In addition to cutting action, check hand size and weight of the tool.